Civica
Financial intelligence for Asia's healthcare markets
 
 
Remember me:

Analysis: Growing health costs in Asia

Mercer’s Rose Kwan and Heena Sethi explain how employers can better manage their healthcare benefits.

Health costs in Asia continue to increase, exacerbated by an aging population, negative lifestyle changes and legislative influence on health – all of which are prompting organisations to consider less conventional methods of developing an employee benefits strategy.

A recent Mercer survey on medical trends reveals that medical costs in 40 countries across the world are set to increase by an average of 9.8% in 2016. In Asia, medical inflation is projected to increase by 11.5% in 2016, outpacing both general price inflation in the region and the global medical inflation average.

Countries expected to have the most alarming medical inflation rates this year include Vietnam at 19.3%, Malaysia at 17.3% and Indonesia at 11.8%. Drilling down further, a varying distribution of inpatient versus outpatient medical inflation becomes apparent. For example, increasing rates in Malaysia are driven primarily by outpatient costs, which account for 18.1% of total costs; in Vietnam, inpatient costs are more prevalent at 22.1%. Such disparity invites employers to take a deeper look at what is driving their own increasing costs.

An increase in non-communicable diseases is the most prominent driver of employee medical costs in Asia, owing to harmful lifestyle habits, an aging workforce, and the cost of medical technology that enables employees to live longer and therefore remain in the workforce longer.

Additional contributors to cost increase in Asia include expanded employee demands, rising incidence of chronic conditions (such as cancer and circulatory system and respiratory diseases) and the increasing prevalence of infectious diseases.

Surprisingly, inpatient claims costs for cancer and gastrointestinal diseases are trending higher than circulatory system diseases in Asia, whereas outpatient claims costs for respiratory conditions outnumber all other conditions. Factors such as increased air pollution and an increase in infectious respiratory diseases, such as tuberculosis, are likely behind the rising number of claims submitted by employees.

In addition, changes in government health care regulations are playing a part in the issue. New legislation from Vietnam’s ministry of health, for example, is expected to increase charges for patients in public hospitals, driving costs up by 30%.

Employers have traditionally focused on conventional solutions when planning and managing their employee benefits programs. Such solutions include “squeezing” insurers for the best price, or reducing the plan design and co-insurance approaches. Although these tactics do provide some relief from increasing medical costs, the results are short-term and reactionary resolutions, and in the case of reducing the coverage level, there will be a negative reaction from employees.

Rather than focusing on temporary, quick-fix remedies, employers should consider shifting toward a more holistic and integrated approach to employee benefits. Developing a more evidence-based approach that leverages both traditional methods and modern advancements in employee benefits is the way of the future.

Data analytics: employers can gauge the health of their employees by analysing claims data, but this offers a single lens and is a retrospective view. A better plan is to look at other data to identify risks and anticipate future claims costs. Drawing on correlations between different components of the medical program, such as employee risk profile and reasons for absenteeism, can help employers understand employee health behaviours before they become too costly. The key is to leverage data already collected and track other metrics to further enhance the data set.

Preventive programmes: employee benefits efforts should include programs that educate employees about how their lifestyle choices have a direct impact on their health. By taking a proactive approach that addresses both biomedical risk factors (like high blood pressure) and behavioural risk factors (such as lack of exercise), employers have a better shot at maintaining and even improving employee health.

Vendor management: increases and changes in providers’ fees account for a large part of increased medical costs, with inpatient and hospital fees being the highest contributors. Employers can evaluate their medical network strategy to understand key cost-drivers from providers, and then implement measures to monitor and manage the costs of services and products.

Employee education: responsibility versus entitlement. Employees have a role when it comes to shopping smartly, making informed choices, and managing medical costs. Employers need to educate their employees on the value of the programme, employees’ role in using the programme wisely, and that the programme is there to protect them from financial loss at the time of medical need.

Total well-being: Stress in the workplace is also key cost-driver. Employers need to avoid thinking of wellness as purely physical and consider their employees’ financial, emotional and mental well-being – communicating a more inclusive definition of wellness.

Overall, the survey revealed that governments across Asia are not providing sufficient health care systems to meet the growing diversity of patient needs, shifting much of the cost burden to the patient. To maintain and even reduce medical costs, employers should work closely with providers to develop more comprehensive benefits strategies that emphasise the importance of total well-being.

Rose Kwan is partner and Asia market business leader for employee health & benefits for Mercer, and Heena Sethi is associate director for employee health and benefits, regional consulting in APAC, for Mercer.

This piece first appeared in BRINK Asia.

Posted on: 11/08/2017 UTC+08:00


News

First REIT, the SGX healthcare real estate investment trust owned by Indonesia’s Lippo Group, has reported a 0.9% rise in distribution per unit (DPU) of S$0.0214 for the third quarter of the year.
Metlifecare, New Zealand’s second-largest listed retirement village operator, plans to spend NZ$240 million (US$167.2 million) to develop a waterfront retirement village at Scott Point, in the Auckland suburb of Hobsonville.
Thonburi Healthcare Group, the country's third largest hospital operator, has inked an MoU with Korea’s Green Cross MS and Green Cross Laboratories.
At its annual general meeting at the end of last week, Gordon Ballantyne, new chief executive of Healthscope, Australia’s second largest private healthcare operator, said that he expected current private hospital market conditions to continue in the short term.
Hong Kong-listed healthcare company China Wah Yan Healthcare plans to consolidate its shares. The move has been pushed onto the company to comply with trading requirements.
Monash IVF Group, Australia’s second largest fertility treatment provider, has appointed David Morris as the CEO and managing director effective from 13 November. After eight years, James Thiedeman stepped down in May.
SGX-listed Singapore Medical Group, a multi-disciplinary specialist healthcare services provider has announced its latest acquisition.
Malaysia's Top Glove is on the acquisition trail. The world’s largest rubber glove manufacture has signed an MoU to buy all the ordinary shares of Eastern Press for M$47.25 million (US$11.18 million) in cash. Eastern Press is principally engaged as a printer and supplier of packaging material. It is also the major supplier of packaging material to Top Glove's subsidiaries in Malaysia.



Analysis

Is there a case to be made for a merger between Metlifecare and Summerset Group, New Zealand’s second and third-largest listed retirement village operators? First NZ Capital reckons so and analyst Arie Dekker makes an eloquent case for it in a new research note.
Stephenson Harwood’s Tom Platts, Ben Hickson and Su Wai Phyo report on key changes implemented by the Myanmar government to facilitate much-needed foreign investment in the country’s healthcare sector.
In the lead-up to the UN’s International Day of the Older Persons on 1 October, Jason Sadler, president, Cigna International Markets, looks at the impact of an aging population on the world’s healthcare system and the role that digital technology will play in meeting this new challenge.
By 2042 there will be more over-65s in Asia than the populations of the Eurozone and North America combined. We look at the business opportunities this creates.
Albert Wong argues that biomedical technology should not be ignored and explains how the Hong Kong Science and Technology Parks Corporation can support it.
Jacob Pope explains why medical tourism remains one of the region’s most significant industries.
APACMed’s Fredrik Nyberg looks at how local and multinational IVD companies are developing novel solutions for Asia’s unique needs.
It is perhaps a curious line in the sand to draw, but the new hospital in Dunedin, the second-largest city in the South Island of New Zealand, is gearing up to be a significant battle in the use of private-public partnership funding in the APAC region.


Civica

Podcasts

AON

Hedge Fund Focus

HealthInvestor Asia twitter feed
HIA Indices