Financial intelligence for Asia's healthcare markets
Remember me:

Analysis: Rising liability awards

Asia is no longer the benign liability environment that it once was. Michael Griffiths, regional director of healthcare at Aon Singapore, explains why.

Imagine you are walking along a footpath in a suburban street somewhere in Asia. Not far ahead of you is a woman on a bicycle, riding on the same footpath. As she rides towards you, a bundle of overhead cables from an adjacent building site falls suddenly on to the street and hits the cyclist, knocking her to the ground.

You rush forward to assist, as do workers from the building site, and everyone is relieved to discover that the cyclist has not been seriously hurt. She is taken to hospital for a check-up, perhaps some treatment for cuts and bruises, but overall it seems that she has had a lucky escape. You would imagine that the owners of the building site will cover the cost of her check-up, repairs to her bicycle, and possibly offer a small apology gift, and that would be the end of the matter.

If this had happened in Australia or the US where people tend to be more litigious, the courts may award higher damages, but here in Asia, people generally do not like to sue, and the courts are generally far more conservative. Well, maybe they used to be, but times have changed.

On 15 October 2009, Ms Siew Pick Chiang, a 42 year-old woman, was cycling along a public path in Singapore, when she was struck by a bundle of overhead cables that had fallen from a building site. Ms Siew suffered only minor physical injuries, but the post-traumatic stress disorder she developed following the accident was so serious that she was hospitalised on at least 18 occasions, and at one stage remained in hospital for over two years. In 2012, she brought legal action against an engineering and construction firm, the main contractor of the building site, seeking damages of S$26 million (US$18.3 million). This amount included over S$13.6 million in medical costs alone, as well as claims for the cost of care givers, loss of income, and S$1.25 million in taxi fares.  

On 1 December last year, the Singapore High Court handed down its judgment. The defendant was found to be fully liable for the injuries suffered by Ms Siew, and was ordered to pay a total of S$8.645 million in damages. This represents the largest ever personal accident award made by the Singapore Courts, nearly S$6 million higher than the previous high water mark.

In our view, this case represents only the latest example of a much wider trend in Asia – that increasing amounts of damages are being awarded by courts.

An award of damages tends to reflect, among other things, the cost of living in the country where it is made. In Asian countries such as Singapore, Japan, Hong Kong, and Korea, the cost of living is now amongst the highest in the world. When it becomes possible for an individual to incur S$13.6 million in medical costs and S$1.25 million in taxi fares, it is inevitable that liability awards in those countries continue to rise.

Insurance brokers can sometimes make for gloomy dinner companions. Part of our job is to highlight to clients the scale of the risks they face, and how and where things could go wrong. Quite understandably, some of my clients respond with scepticism when I tell them that Asia is not the benign liability environment that it once was. They ask to see the proof. In my view, the Singapore High Court has just provided it.

Posted on: 23/02/2017 UTC+08:00


Medical rubber glove manufacturer Hartalega Holdings has incorporated a 70% owned subsidiary company in China called Foshan Dynamic.
Singapore-based dental group Unity Denticare is the latest company to sign an MOU with Malaysian online healthcare booking app BookDoc. The company has now pretty much cornered the dental market in Singapore. At the end of March signed an MOU with Q&M Dental Group, which operates the largest network of private dental outlets in the island state.
The majority of bondholders have decided to redeem their paper in Singapore-listed integrated healthcare services and facilities provider International Healthway Corporation.
Leading domestic media organisation Singapore Press Holdings is moving into healthcare with the acquisition of Orange Valley Healthcare from KV Asia Capital for S$164 million (US$118 million). The acquisition will be funded with a mixture of cash and debt.
TalkMed Group, a provider of medical oncology and palliative care health care services, has reported a 1.7% decline in profits for the first quarter of the year to S$8.4 million (US$6 million) on revenues that rose 1.4% to S$16.2 million.
Care home operator Pine Care Group has sold a care home in Kwun Tong, Kowloon, for HK$6.6 million (US$853,000) to Goal Achiever Ventures, a company incorporated in the British Virgin Islands.
Shares in Aoxin Q&M Dental Group (AQMD), a spin off of Singapore’s Q&M Dental Group, jumped 17.5% on their SGX debut today. The company raised S$9.1 million (US$6.5 million) selling 57 million shares at S$0.20 each on the Catalist board. SAC Capital handled the deal.
Wenzhou Kangning Hospital, the largest private psychiatric specialty care service provider in China, has delayed plans to list on the Shanghai Stock Exchange, thanks to difficulties with its lawyers.


Jonathan Tan, director of Asia Pacific Risk Centre, explains how an aging population and the rise in non-communicable diseases is threatening the affordability of insurance premiums across the region.
“The Asia Pacific healthcare sector’s growth trajectory will be decidedly positive. The expansion of universal healthcare across the region will boost utilisation of medical services, even as the prevalence of chronic diseases rise in tandem with the shift in lifestyles and an ageing population,” says BMI Research in Singapore in a new report on healthcare in Asia.
After a visit to Myanmar, Jiadi Yu, principal investment officer at the IFC in Hong Kong, is optimistic about the country’s health market.
Amid questions about the direction of the global economy, investors doubled down on healthcare as a safe haven in 2016, driving up both the number and the value of deals, according to Bain & Company’s sixth Global Healthcare Private Equity and Corporate M&A Report.
Susann Roth, senior social development specialist, Asian Development Bank, explains how Vietnam is seizing the opportunity of digital health.
The Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation’s new medical technologies and pharmaceuticals roadmap sets out a path for how Australia could become an important player in medical technologies and pharmaceuticals, which is expected to grow to almost A$3 trillion (US$2.3 trillion) globally by 2025.
The takeover of Australian private hospital operator Pulse Health by Healthe Care, Australia’s third largest hospital operator has been put on hold for two months. Yesterday Pulse applied to the Supreme Court of New South Wales to delay a scheme meeting planned for Wednesday this week to approve its takeover, until 1 May.
The renounceable non-underwritten 11-for-200 rights issue for SGX-listed private healthcare provider Health Management International (HMI) has received strong interest from investors. It had a 145.7% subscription rate, raising gross proceeds of S$18.5 million (US$13.1 million).
EducationInvestor Global

The Future of Healthcare in Asia

Round table

Download the round table here

Hedge Fund Focus

HealthInvestor Asia twitter feed
HIA Indices